What Makes a Great Burger? Let McCray’s Show You How It’s Done!

The Difference Between a Good Burger and a Great Burger

If you love burgers, you’ve already got it: a solid mental image of the ideal burger with your perfect toppings. The bun. The cheese. The beef (or turkey; we don’t discriminate). At McCray’s Tavern, we’ve got a few ideas of our own about what sets a burger a few steps above the rest.


Our talented chefs go above and beyond in their search to craft the best burgers in midtown, and they’ve let us in on the secret of what distinguishes a good burger from a great burger. (Hint: ours are pretty great!) 


The Meat

What makes a good burger? We’re going to have to say that meat is the most important element. Good burgers feature hot, juicy, well-seasoned meat. Great burgers go one step further, consisting of fresh, never frozen beef, and seasoned with a proprietary blend of spices perfected by the chefs at McCray’s. 


Great burgers don’t skimp on the meat, either. Experienced chefs recognize that in great burgers, the patty is the star of the show, and should never be dwarfed by other burger accessories. The grilling process is equally important for a great burger. Burgers will always be cooked to your standards at McCray’s, with each patty becoming part of a mouthwatering masterpiece. And that’s only the beginning!



The Cheese

While good burgers include some tasty, melty cheese, great burgers can offer so much more. Think of it, several slices of the mouthwatering, high-quality, real cheese of your choice atop a piping-hot burger patty. Pepper jack? Sharp cheddar? Smoked gouda? Whatever you prefer, a great burger showcases it with panache. Get cheesy with your burger by decking it out however you like.



The Bun

Good burgers have decent buns that are able to contain their contents without falling apart. Great burgers have toasted, buttered buns that taste like the homemade bread fresh from your grandma’s oven. The buns are like the bows on a present, and their importance should be appreciated. They hold the burger together while it’s in your hands, showcase its beauty, and then with a bite allow you to reach the delicious contents inside. 


At McCray’s Tavern, our burger buns are always warm and soft, but substantial enough to maintain their texture and hold all of their juicy, burgery contents together beautifully. We appreciate a great bun, and only serve the best because of it!




The Whole Grilled-to-Your-Satisfaction Package


Good burgers have the basics you need for life and happiness. You know, the burger staples: cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and maybe some bacon or some sauce to kick it up a notch. Some good burgers even go overboard with a ton of delicious stuff that doesn’t necessarily jive and is just meant to make up for what the burger patty lacks.


Great burgers keep it simple, featuring tried and tested and 100% reliable flavor combinations. They don’t throw 84 different savory flavors at you in the hope that they’ll impress you with their large selection rather than their quality. McCray’s burgers are all favorites. Some feature fancy combos like our Tavern Grizzly, with an onion ring, bacon, and cheddar cheese, or our Matador, with smoked Gouda, Guinness BBQ sauce, and pickled jalapeños. Every combination is a longtime favorite, and none go so far as to overpower the classic flavor of our beef patties. Our burgers are instead enhanced by a unique twist that can’t be found anywhere else.


Get a Great Burger at McCray’s Tavern Midtown


Experience a great McCray’s Tavern burger for yourself at our
midtown Atlanta restaurant location today. Check out our other menu items as well, and bring the whole family for a night out at one of the best tavern restaurants in Atlanta! 


Best Burgers in Smyrna
April 29, 2025
Savor comfort foods from around the world at McCray’s Tavern in Smyrna! Enjoy Shrimp & Grits, Fish & Chips, Smash Burgers, and more in a warm, inviting atmosphere.
burgers & beer
April 29, 2025
Discover McCray's Tavern on the Beltline, Atlanta's premier destination for delicious food, craft cocktails, and prime people-watching along the vibrant Eastside Trail.
McCray's Spring Cocktail
April 29, 2025
Celebrate spring at McCray's Tavern in Lawrenceville with our innovative cocktail menu featuring locally sourced ingredients and seasonal flavors. Join us for a refreshing experience!
East Cobb signature cocktails
April 29, 2025
Explore McCray's Tavern East Cobb's signature cocktails, from our exclusive Maker's Mark Old Fashioned to the spicy-sweet Pineapple Jalapeño Margarita. Join us for an exceptional drink experience.​
McCray's in the Heart of Midtown
April 29, 2025
Experience the perfect blend of classic American tavern ambiance and vibrant Midtown Atlanta energy at McCray's Tavern Midtown. Join us for creative dishes, craft beverages, and engaging events.
Unforgettable Dining Experience
March 13, 2025
Experience unforgettable dining at McCray’s Tavern East Cobb with chef-driven dishes, craft drinks, and top-notch service. Perfect for any occasion! Visit us today!
McCray's Beltline
March 13, 2025
Discover the best hidden gems along Atlanta’s Beltline, just steps from McCray’s Tavern. Explore local art, parks, bars, and markets for the perfect adventure before or after your meal!
Best McCray's Burger
March 13, 2025
Discover the best burgers in Smyrna at McCray’s Tavern! From classic favorites to gourmet creations, our handcrafted burgers are a must-try. Visit us today or order online!
Southern Gastropub
March 13, 2025
Experience the best of Southern gastropub dining at McCray’s Tavern in Lawrenceville. Discover chef-crafted dishes, craft beer, and a lively atmosphere. Book your table today!
Local Breweries & Pubs
By Meghan Meghan March 13, 2025
Discover the best of Atlanta’s craft beer scene at McCray’s Tavern Midtown! Enjoy a rotating selection of local brews, tap takeovers, and beer pairing events. Stop by today for great food, great beer, and great vibes in Midtown Atlanta
More Posts