What Makes the Ideal Sandwich

McCray's Grilled Sandwich

A sandwich is a classic lunchtime staple, but what makes a truly great sandwich? Is it the bread? The fillings? The condiments? We did a little research to determine exactly what separates a good sandwich from a great one. Keep reading to learn our tips for making the perfect sandwich every time.


Start With Good Bread

The first step to making a great sandwich is to start with good bread. Since the bread forms the foundation of the sandwich, it's important to use a high-quality loaf that will taste delicious and hold up well to the fillings. A good piece of bread should be delicious to eat all by itself before adding any other ingredients. Our favorite types of bread for sandwiches are sourdough, ciabatta, whole wheat, and baguettes.


Add Flavorful Fillings

Once you've selected your bread, it's time to add fillings! When filling a sandwich, the sky's the limit; however, it is important that the filling compliment the bread. For instance, if you're using a hearty bread like sourdough, you'll want a filling that can stand up to it, such as flavorful, well-seasoned meat like roasted pork or buffalo chicken. Be sure to use high-quality, well-sourced meat for top-notch results. For the non-meat eaters, crisp roasted vegetables, hummus, or avocado are perfect sandwich fillings that will taste excellent and satiate your hunger.


Don't Forget the Condiments

Condiments are what take a sandwich from good to great. They should be applied sparingly so as not to overwhelm the sandwich's other flavors. A touch of mayo or mustard can add some much-needed moisture, while lettuce or tomato can add a pop of freshness. Pickles, hot sauce, and other savory toppings can also help round out the flavor of your sandwich. Different condiment combinations are where you get to flex your creative muscles and find the perfect blend for your palate. Just be careful not to go overboard—a small amount of condiment goes a long way!


Grilled Sandwich

Grilling Makes Everything Better

If you want your sandwich to be next-level delicious, try grilling it! Using a pan or outdoor grill gives your sandwich a nice char and helps all the flavors melt together beautifully. If you don't have access to a grill, no worries—your sandwich will still be tasty without one.


Take the Time to Enjoy Every Bite

The final and most important step in making the perfect sandwich is to enjoy it! Make sure to take some time to savor all of the delicious flavors and textures that you've carefully put together. A great sandwich is a work of art and should be treated as such. Sit down, relax, and enjoy every bite.


Visit McCray's to Find Your Ideal Sandwich 

At McCray's, we take pride in creating the perfect sandwich for you. We have an extensive Lawrenceville menu of delicious options, each made with high-quality ingredients and attention to detail. Whether you're in the mood for something classic or want to try something new, we have something for everyone. Stop by today and find your perfect sandwich!


French Toast | McCray's Tavern
July 9, 2025
Locals love McCray’s Smyrna for its unbeatable rooftop views, laid-back vibe, and craveable menu. Discover why it’s become a favorite neighborhood spot in every season.
Brunch | McCray's Tavern
July 9, 2025
McCray’s Tavern on the Beltline turns Sundays into something special with laid-back brunch, craft cocktails, and unbeatable people-watching in the heart of Atlanta.
Bourbon Whiskey | McCray's Tavern
July 9, 2025
McCray’s in Smyrna celebrates whiskey with deep roots, Southern soul, and a handpicked selection of bourbons, ryes, and small-batch spirits worth sipping slowly.
Loaded Potato Chips | McCray's Tavern
July 9, 2025
From weekly trivia nights and 40+ beers on tap to crowd-pleasing comfort food, McCray’s East Cobb brings together everything you love about a classic local tavern.
Burger | McCray's Tavern
July 9, 2025
Soak up summer with rooftop views, live music, and local brews at McCray’s Tavern Midtown. The perfect spot for summer nights in Atlanta.
Midtown Happy Hour
June 25, 2025
Discover why McCray’s Tavern in Midtown Atlanta feels like home. From rooftop dining to a warm vibe, indulge in great food, drinks, and city skyline views.
French Toast Brunch | McCray's Tavern
June 25, 2025
Discover how McCray’s East Cobb elevates everyday favorites with fresh ingredients and unique twists. Join us for unforgettable classic dishes and a welcoming atmosphere!
McCray's Tavern Burger
June 25, 2025
Explore the rich history of the burger and how McCray’s Tavern keeps it classic yet innovative. Discover their signature creations and fresh twists on this timeless dish.
Craft Beer | McCray's Tavern
June 25, 2025
Discover the history of craft beer and how McCray’s Tavern highlights Atlanta’s finest brews. Explore local partnerships and a beer menu crafted for every palate.
Local and Seasonal Ingredients | McCray's Tavern
June 25, 2025
Explore McCray’s sustainable dining approach. Enjoy local and seasonal ingredients that support farmers, preserve the earth, and create fresher, tastier meals.